OTHER PRACTICE AREAS
Forged and Altered Wills in Florida: Challenging an Invalid Estate Document
For a will to be valid in Florida, it must meet strict formal requirements under Florida Statutes §732.502. When a will was never actually signed by the person whose name appears on it, or when a document was physically altered after it was properly executed, it does not meet those requirements and can be challenged in court.
These cases require prompt legal action. The deadlines for contesting a will in Florida are strict, and waiting can permanently foreclose your options.
PersanteZuroweste brings and defends actions challenging the validity of wills and trust documents in Florida. If you believe that you may need legal assistance, please contact us for a free consultation at (727) 796-7666.
Key Takeaway
- Florida law sets specific execution requirements. Under §732.502, a will must be signed by the testator in the presence of two witnesses, and both witnesses must sign the will in the presence of each other and the testator. A will that does not satisfy these requirements is not valid regardless of its contents.
- A forged signature makes a will void from the start. If the testator’s signature was never actually made by them, the will has no legal force. It cannot be admitted to probate, and if it has already been admitted, it can be revoked through a Petition for Revocation of Probate under Florida Statutes §733.109.
- Post-execution alterations invalidate the changes. A properly executed will that was physically altered after signing is invalid in its altered form. Even a single material change made after execution can be challenged.
- The deadline to act is strict. Under §733.212, if you received a formal Notice of Administration, you could have as little as 20 days to object.
- The burden of proof matters. There is a presumption under Florida law that the testator was of sound mind when the will was executed. The person challenging the will on grounds of forgery or alteration has the burden of proving their claim. Strong evidence, including document examination and witness testimony, is typically required.
Types of Document Fraud in Florida Estates
Outright Forgery: A will where the testator’s signature was forged. These cases often involve a document that appeared shortly after death that no family member had seen before, or a will that contradicts the decedent’s known estate planning wishes.
Alteration After Signing: A properly executed will that was physically changed after the signing ceremony. Florida law does not permit a will to be amended through physical changes to the document after execution. Any such changes are invalid.
Fraudulent Codicils: A codicil that was forged or altered is subject to the same legal challenge as a forged will and can be set aside while the underlying will remains in effect.
Fraudulent Trust Amendments: A trust amendment made by fraud, without the grantor’s knowledge, or through a forged signature can be challenged and declared invalid even if the original trust document was properly executed.
How These Cases Are Built
- Initial review. We examine the document itself, the circumstances under which it appeared, and the timeline of its execution relative to the decedent’s health, relationships, and estate planning history.
- Document examination. Forensic document examiners analyze the physical document for signs of alteration, including ink inconsistencies, paper characteristics, evidence of erasures, and insertions.
- Handwriting analysis. A forensic handwriting expert compares the signature on the questioned document with known authentic signatures to determine whether the signature is genuine.
- Witness testimony. People who were present at the signing, who knew the decedent’s estate planning intentions, or who can speak to the circumstances under which the document appeared are often central to the case.
- Medical and financial records. If the testator was hospitalized, cognitively impaired, or otherwise incapacitated at the time the will purports to have been signed, medical records can establish that the signing could not have occurred as represented.
- Petition for Revocation of Probate. If the will has already been admitted to probate, the appropriate proceeding to challenge it is a Petition for Revocation of Probate under §733.109. The contestant bears the burden of establishing the grounds on which revocation is sought under Florida Probate Rule 5.275.
What the Court Can Do
Set Aside the Forged or Altered Document: The court can declare the document invalid in whole or in part and revoke its admission to probate.
Return to a Prior Valid Will: If a prior valid will exists, the court can give effect to that document instead. If no prior valid will exists, the estate passes under Florida’s intestate succession laws.
Surcharge and Damages: If the fraud was carried out by a fiduciary, they can be held personally liable for the resulting harm to the estate and its beneficiaries.
Criminal Referral: Will forgery can constitute a criminal offense under Florida law. Civil proceedings and criminal investigations can proceed simultaneously.
Frequently Asked Questions
What if the will looks suspicious but I do not have proof it was forged?
You do not need to have proof in hand before contacting an attorney. Evidence in forgery cases is frequently developed through the litigation process itself, including court-ordered document examination and formal discovery.
How long do I have to challenge a forged will in Florida?
Under Florida Statutes §733.212(3), if you received a formal Notice of Administration, you have as little as 20 days to file a will contest.
What if the will was validly signed but someone later made handwritten changes to it?
Handwritten changes made to a will after it was properly executed are not valid under Florida law, even if the testator made the changes themselves. To amend a will, a new will or a properly executed codicil satisfying the requirements of §732.502 is required.
Can a trust document be challenged on the same grounds as a will?
Yes. Trust documents are subject to similar execution requirements and the same potential for fraud and forgery. A trust amendment or restatement that was forged, executed without the grantor’s knowledge, or altered after signing can be challenged and declared invalid.
What happens to the estate if the will is thrown out?
If the forged or altered will is set aside and a valid prior will exists, the estate is distributed under that prior will. If no valid prior will exists, the estate passes under Florida’s intestate succession laws.
